Elevation Marketing
Ergon Fuels
UX Strategy Framework
Strategy & Research
Recommendation: keep residential and existing-customer journeys continuous while adding separate commercial journeys by product/service and by industry/application. Each of the five parts gives the source basis, the problem, a testable proposed response, the evidence gap and the review decision.
1Assess the existing website experience & identify friction points
Working proposalSource basis
- Earlier-source audit analysis (21-sheet workbook, pending verification against the final Nov 13, 2026 24-sheet workbook): impressions -37% since the August rebuild; Semrush keywords -53%; 47 top-10 keywords (16 non-branded); 17 issues (8 High, 6 High/Medium, 3 Medium).
- Live crawl, Nov 15, 2026: 318 discovered sitemap/navigation URLs; no separate blog; 8 /portal/ and 237 /safety-meeting/ archive URLs are proposed exclusions, pending business, legal and content-value review.
The problem
- The current site is organized around residential/local propane and offers no top-10 visibility for prices, tanks, switching or any commercial segment (earlier-source figure).
- Commercial products and applications have no dedicated, findable paths today.
Proposed response
- PROPOSED: treat missing commercial and residential decision content as the primary friction, ahead of visual redesign.
- PROPOSED: log all audited issues with template/URL, owner and QA result once the final workbook rows are verified.
Evidence gap
- Customer-reported friction from the interview findings deck (not reviewed for this console) pending source
- Issue counts are earlier-source and provisional until checked against the final workbook.
Review decision needed
- Prioritize fixing missing commercial journeys and residential decision content before a visual redesign?
2Align business objectives with user needs
Working proposalSource basis
- Earlier-source audit (May-Oct 2026, GSC): 74% is the branded share of total GSC clicks. The earlier search-behavior table reports about 5,100 brand-containing-query clicks, about 93% of clicks in its query dataset. Different source datasets/denominators; no reconciliation implied. Provisional until the final workbook is checked.
- Organic leads/conversions: UNKNOWN - GA4 key events not exported for the period. Not zero.
- Final workbook, Commercial Fuel Keywords overview (read Nov 16): 25 application groups; 211,740 aggregate group volume; 853 keywords found; the sheet warns groups can overlap.
The problem
- Two needs compete: protecting residential/branded continuity during the Lampton Love → Ergon Fuels transition, and building commercial demand that the current model does not serve.
- Without GA4 key events, business impact cannot be baselined.
Proposed response
- PROPOSED: preserve residential customer continuity as one need (dual-brand messaging, existing-customer paths) rather than the organizing model for the whole site.
- PROPOSED: treat commercial demand as separate buying journeys, prioritized after Ergon confirms which products, applications and service areas it actually serves.
- PROPOSED: configure and test GA4 key events before launch; set no lead target until a baseline exists.
Evidence gap
- 211,740 is aggregate overlapping group volume - not unique searches, unique keywords, leads, revenue or additive addressable market.
- Actual Ergon commercial service coverage is unconfirmed.
- Who owns GA4 and can export historical key events?
Review decision needed
- Agree that residential continuity and commercial growth are separate, parallel objectives?
- Who validates commercial service coverage, and by when?
3Priority audiences, tasks & user journeys
Working proposalSource basis
- Commercial Fuel Keywords overview (final workbook): source note attributes segments/applications to interview deck slides 28-32 and Semrush US Nov 12-13, 2026. This is direct workbook evidence and SECONDARY interview evidence - the slides themselves have not been read.
- Earlier-source audit: residential buyers search by town, price and tank decisions; commercial by delivery and forklift.
The problem
- A single 'Commercial' bucket hides very different buyers: a fleet manager buying diesel and fuel cards, a contractor needing jobsite fuel and temporary heat, poultry operations using propane heat, grain-drying operations, and farm fuel buyers.
- Existing residential customers need account/help paths that should not be mixed with prospect journeys.
Proposed response
- PROPOSED service/product intents: diesel (clear, dyed), gasoline, DEF, propane/autogas, fuel cards, bulk/fleet fueling, storage/tank monitoring.
- PROPOSED application intents (hypotheses to validate): transportation/logistics; heavy industry/construction (jobsite fuel, temporary heat, equipment rental, process heat, storage/SPCC); wholesale (gas/propane, cylinder fill); forklift/warehousing; hospitality/food trucks; commercial buildings/builders; agriculture (poultry, grain drying, farm fuel); marinas/ethanol-free gas; multi-site tank monitoring; public-sector fleets.
- PROPOSED residential paths, kept separate: existing customer (account, bill pay, budget plan, help/safety) and prospect (town, pricing, tanks, switching).
Evidence gap
- Motivations, objections and vocabulary per audience - interview findings deck (not reviewed for this console) pending source
- Raw interview transcripts not recovered pending source
- Residential appliance detail (slide 8 of the deck) not recovered pending source
- Application groups are market hypotheses, not confirmed Ergon offerings.
Review decision needed
- Which commercial products/services and applications does Ergon actually serve, and where?
- Which 3-5 commercial journeys are priority for launch?
4Future-state UX principles & experience requirements
Working proposalSource basis
- Commercial Fuel Keywords overview (final workbook, read Nov 16): 25 overlapping application groups.
- Earlier-source audit: 32 striking-distance keywords; 34 curated opportunities.
The problem
- A generic quote form cannot route a diesel fleet inquiry, an urgent out-of-fuel request and a residential tank question to the right team.
Proposed response
- PROPOSED commercial quote fields (for validation, not confirmed operational availability): product/service · application/industry · location/service area · volume and frequency · service need (delivery, storage, monitoring, cards). pending input
- PROPOSED: separate urgent requests from routine quote intent with a distinct path. No emergency-service or response-time promise is made unless Ergon confirms it.
- PROPOSED: residential existing-customer/account/help paths separate from prospect quote paths.
- PROPOSED: crosslink product and application pages instead of duplicating thin pages per keyword group.
- PROPOSED: mobile-first templates to WCAG 2.1 AA; tracked CTAs per journey.
Evidence gap
- Routing owners, CRM handoff and service hours are unconfirmed.
- Forms system for the new WordPress build is unconfirmed.
Review decision needed
- Approve the proposed field set and urgent/routine split for operations validation?
5Migration-specific risks & opportunities
Working proposalSource basis
- Live crawl, Nov 15, 2026: 318 discovered URLs; 70 proposed public-page redirect rows. Observed Nov 15 crawl check: ergonfuels.com redirected to ergon.com.
- Earlier-source audit: impressions -37% since the August rebuild; head-to-head losses 77 vs target 20.
The problem
- A second visibility drop at cutover is the central risk. Branded demand must transfer to Ergon Fuels; the earlier audit snapshot showed no measurable search volume for the new brand.
- New commercial pages are net-new destinations - they have no legacy equivalents and are not automatic 301 targets.
Proposed response
- PROPOSED: deploy direct one-hop 301s at cutover (day 0) to intent-matched, approved destinations with content parity; no blanket home-page mapping.
- PROPOSED: 30/60/90 days are monitoring, repairs and growth - never deferred redirect deployment.
Evidence gap
- Destination URLs are unapproved; affected redirects depend on confirmed commercial offerings and the final sitemap.
- Staging QA has not occurred.
Review decision needed
- Agree priority commercial branches today so destination URLs can be mapped and approved?